Back in 2015, I wrote "You Know You're From Brewster, NY When." It was a huge hit, as is often the case with things I do. My editor asked me if I thought I could do a sequel and I said I would. This morning I got to work on it without referring to Part 1, but after comparing the two, I realized that there were some duplicates, which means there are certain things that just stuck with me about my hometown. Here is the sequel:

You know you are from Brewster when... (Part 2) 

  • You know where Heidi's Motel is but you have never stayed there.
  • You see a Bear logo and shout "Yeah Bears!"
  • You sat next to my Grandma at at Brewster Bears Football game.
Lou's phone
  • You worked at a deli, grocery store, pumped gas or sold clothes at the Danbury mall growing up. Those were your options.
  • You know you could catch a sweet pick up basketball game on a Wednesday night in the St. Lawrence gym.
  • You've made your own bacon egg & cheese, in the kitchen at the North Brewster Deli because the Pozzuto's are awesome.
Google Instant Street View
  • People say Tom Selleck has the best mustache, you disagree strongly. Everyone knows John Martino has the world's best mustache.
  • Vinny Savastano has beat you in a foot race.
  • Seeing Norm's empty and boarded up makes you legit sad.
Google Instant Street View
  • You know all of your shop teachers combined, have a total of twelve fingers.
  • You've tricked Bev into thinking a "Post-It" note was a hall pass.
  • You know a meeting at the Electrozone field meant it was time for some baseball.
Google Instant Street View
  • You hung out on Ice Pond Road when there were no houses there.
  • You heard me on the radio in the morning and saw me parking cars at Beecher Funeral Home in the afternoon. Sorry for your loss.
  • You refuse to shop anywhere but Kobackers. (Thanks for your patronage on behalf of Uncle Frank & Aunt Kim)
Lou's phone
  • You know that "Jealousy is the Green-Eyed Monster" Thanks to Ms. German.
  • You know that Danbury bars closing, meant there were 25 minutes until a fight would break out.
  • A trip to see a friend in Putnam Lake started with "A left at the monument," involved a dirt-bike, Budweiser and ended by attempting to elude the authorities.
Google Instant Street View
  • You know Hickory, Oakwood, Maple, Elmwood & South (H.O.M.E.S.) became a war-zone on Halloween.
  • "Bigger, Faster, Stronger" was your first fitness program.
  • Tyrone texts you everyday:
Tyrone Mayfield
  • You've been to the Fore N' Aft, The Hunt Club, Polo's or Miami Heat.
  • The first day of school meant a hideous tradition that we will never tell our kids about.
  • A school field trip meant a one minute walk or five minute drive to the Walter Brewster House.
Google Instant Street View
  • You you still know the way to the reservoir rope-swing.
  • You know that The Pistons dominated Brewster Youth Basketball, despite having no "stars." We didn't need them, we had Matt & Mark Moore, ripping boards and playing team basketball. We also had the greatest coach in the history of basketball, Dick Moore.
  • Steve Presti has always fixed your car. Don't call him to tell him I wrote about him, his phone is already ringing off the hook.
Google Instant Street View
  • Bonnie Colombo helped you understand the permit process at 1 Main Street.
  • You know the kids from "The Heights" are a different breed.
  • You claim to know Ava Fabian, even if you were not friends with her.
Getty Images
  • Seeing the Cameo theater boarded up makes you sick to your stomach.
  • You've attended a wedding reception at the VFW.
  • "The Beach" meant Tonetta or Wells Park.
Google Instant Street View
  • A "Project Adventure Trust-Fall" meant your friends would let you fall to the ground.
  • You know at least four people who were not permitted to "walk" at graduation.
  • You've been invited to Rocco Drive (Maybe you saw this guy there)
Angela Milano
  • Someone says "we are having a party" and you are astonished to learn it's not taking place in the woods or in a hotel room.
  • You, or someone you know has crashed into the mailbox at the end of this sharp turn on Foggintown Road. (You know who you are, some of you have done it twice)
Google Instant Street View
  • Kelly Quinn has temporarily damaged your eyesight with his bright smile.
Lou's phone
  • You have zero patience for explaining how there is a Brewster/Southeast, their relationship to The Village of Brewster or how the Putnam Lake kids go to Brewster Schools.
  • You have zero patience for explaining the difference between the Brewster and Brewster North train stations.
Google Instant Street View
  • You've never been on a Metro-North train without alcohol on your person.
  • You played a pick-up basketball game at Markel Park against a guy nicknamed "Swamp Thing."
  • You know that any "road trip" that involved two or more Brewster kids ended in disaster.
Lou's phone
  • You had a physical fight with someone that ended up being your friend.
  • You know Judy Cleary was the world's greatest Guidance Counselor.
  • You've caught a Touchdown pass from this dude under the "Friday Night Lights." (That's Uncle Pete to me, you probably have other names for him) 
Angela Milano
  • You are a grown up and when someone drops something in the kitchen, you still shout D--- ! (Low Voice, Slow, sustained delivery that ends in a high pitch)
  • You know what this face means. This particular night, it meant encouraging a drunk stranger to dance and laughing at him while he did. It's also the night we went to ALCS Game 5, he forgot the tickets, I lost my wallet so that dude was our entertainment in the Bronx.  
Lou's phone
  • You've talked Yankees with Liz Hudak.
Lou's phone
  • You know Buddo. (Dude loves wigs and hats) 
Lou's phone
  • You grow up the same way, did everything together, ended up on very different paths and remain friends.
Lou's phone

Yeah Bears!

Twitter/Brewster Bears

Listen to the Home of Rock 'N' Roll i95 at 95.1 WRKI-FM. Stream us live through the i95 Rock mobile app, your Alexa-enabled device, Google Home or right here on the website

Connect with i95 on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and our mobile app