For 50 years during the the 1800s, the New Milford village of Gaylordsville had an identity crisis. Its name kept flipping back and forth between Gaylordsville and Merwinsville, based on whether the Gaylords or the Merwins were in charge of the post office.

WRKI and WINE logo
Get our free mobile app

The history of the Merwinsville Hotel began in 1837 when surveyors for the Housatonic Railroad were discussing the best route for the railroad up the valley through Gaylordsville. They spent a few nights in the hotel, west of the river, run by Sylvanus Merwin, a shrewd businessman.

Upon learning in 1842 that the Housatonic Railroad would be routed through the area, he purchased land that required it to cross land he controlled.

He then negotiated with the railroad executives for the placement of the hotel, requiring that the train stop there for a meal and that the station be named "Merwinsville." As a result, the hotel was open for service in 1843 when the train service was inaugurated.

The Merwinsville Hotel: A Slice of Gaylordsville History

You're about to embark on a fascinating true story about a town eight miles north of New Milford that, back in the day, had an identity problem.
Was the town named Merwinsville, or was it Gaylordsville?

How the Great State of CT Played a Crucial Role in the Revolutionary War

New Haven, Connecticut Named One of 52 Places to See in the World

More From WRKI and WINE