The Creepiest Backroads in Putnam County, New York

Putnam County, New York looks like the definition of quiet. It’s scenic, it’s peaceful, and for the most part, nothing really feels out of the ordinary. But if you spend enough time talking to people who grew up there—or anyone who’s driven those backroads late at night—you start to hear the same thing over and over again.

Get our free mobile app

There’s just something… off about certain roads.

Not in a dramatic, horror-movie way. It’s more subtle than that. A weird feeling. A stretch of road you avoid after dark. A place where your headlights don’t seem to reach as far as they should. And the strangest part? Every town in Putnam County seems to have at least one.

The Creepiest Backroads in Putnam County, New York

Putnam County might seem quiet on the surface, but once you start digging, you realize there’s no shortage of eerie backroads and local legends. Ask around, and just about everyone can point you to a stretch of pavement that feels a little different after the sun goes down. Here are five of the most talked-about roads in the area.

Gallery Credit: Lou Milano

I grew up driving these roads, so I can say with some confidence—they’re creepy. No question about it. There are stretches where the trees feel a little too close, the silence gets a little too loud, and you catch yourself checking the rearview more than usual. But at the same time, they’re mine. I know every turn, every weird dip in the road, every spot where your headlights hit just right and make your brain play tricks on you.

So yeah, if the hills have eyes out there, I’ll be fine. We’ve got an understanding. But if you’re just passing through? Different story. You might want to keep it moving… and maybe don’t take the scenic route after dark.

You Know You're from Putnam Lake, NY If...

Putnam Lake is a Hamlet of the Town of Patterson, NY. "The Lake" was, and continues to be a great place to raise a family but it most certainly is not boring. People from surrounding communities have a lot to say about "Lakers", they just don't do it to your face.

Putnam Lake has a personality all it's own. "The Lake" is loaded with great people with wonderful personalities that all seem to have a few things in common. This is why it will be easy for those of you who lived there, to identify with the "You Know You're From Putnam Lake If.....Examples.

Gallery Credit: Lou Milano

Vacant Putnam Lake Properties

Putnam Lake is a Hamlet of the Town of Patterson In Putnam County, NY. Originally, the community was a vacation getaway for city folks who wanted Lake property in the country. Today, it’s not any kind of weekend or destination getaway but a great place to live, I would know, I grew up there. Like any small town, Putnam Lake, NY has its setbacks. It’s difficult to open any business and even harder to keep the doors open. These are some of the long vacant commercial properties of “The Lake.”

Gallery Credit: Lou Milano

Top 10 Ways to Describe Putnam Lake in 5 Words or Less

If you asked someone who never lived in Putnam Lake to describe it, they'd probably give you some run around about how complicated it is to boil down. If you lived there you know that it's quite simple and it can be done in five words or less. Here at the Top 10 Ways to Describe Putnam Lake in 5 Words Or Less.

Gallery Credit: Lou Milano

Categories: Articles