Best Restaurants in Brewster, Mahopac, Carmel, and Pawling
We have a tons of loyal listeners in Dutchess and Putnam counties in New York state and at times, I don't show enough love to our New York state friends. With that said, after searching "Yelp," Trip Advisor," and "Open Table," I've compiled a list of New York state restaurants that were given the highest ratings by these websites. Reviews are on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being the best.
McKinney & Doyle is on 10 Charles Coleman Boulevard in Pawling and my wife says it's awesome. For some reason she goes to this fine dining establishment only with her girlfriends. Hmmmm, I wonder if she's got the hots for one of the waiters. Anyway, dishes recommended are the "Ultimate Grilled Cheese" with sliced pears, smoked bacon, and monterey jack cheese on homemade grilled cinnamon bread and the "Smokehouse Omelette," with cheese, bacon, peppers, onion, along with a side of potatoes and fresh fruit. They've won many awards for their wine list plus there's a bakery attached to the restaurant that features homemade pastries, danish, cookies, layer cake, etc. OMG!!
"Northern Smoke" is at 166 Stoneleigh Ave in Carmel, NY and is real bit barbecue cooked low n' slow with cherry and hickory. Everybody raves about their "sampler platter" with pulled pork, brisket, and barbecued ribs with mac n' cheese and sweet potato tots. Whatever you do, try one of the homemade barbecue sauces, especially the apple bourbon sauce. Northern Smoke received between 4 and 5 stars on every review I read!
The Carriage House in Patterson has been such a popular eatery in Patterson, NY, their Mahopac customers were thrilled when they opened a Carriage House at 887 Route 6 in Mahopac. Customers rave about the "Au Poivre Burger" which is peppercorn crusted with swiss cheese, applewood smoked bacon, baby arugula, peppercorn cream sauce on a brioche bun! Raves also go out to The Ultimate Ruben. Customers love the comfortable "woodsy" atmosphere and the roaring fire in the winter. The Carriage House also features many craft beers on tap.
The Arch is a fine dining restaurant at 1292 Rt.22 in Brewster, NY. Fine dining means impeccable service and a sommelier(wine expert) and it also means classy and pricey. Reviews come in at close to 5's across the board. I've been to The Arch and must agree on the rave reviews! There are not too many restaurants with beef wellington on the menu, which was my choice for dinner and it was amazing! Zagat Review named The Arch one of the top restaurants outside of New York City. Other recommended dishes were the duck and the seared bay scallops. Do yourself a favor and save some room for dessert.
The Country Kitchen at 564 North Main St. in Brewster is a casual traditional American restaurant serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The restaurant is family owned and has been getting glowing reviews for the last 25 years. The cornbeef hash is homemade, the service is exceptional, and everything is delicious. The Country Kitchen gets almost straight 5's across the board! Soups are amazing made from fresh vegetables grown right next door. Customers rave about their incredible breakfasts which are served all day long!