Hypothetical: Giants vs. Pats Super Bowl Part 3 – Who Ya Takin’?

Every single person I have asked has said that they want this rematch -- Brady versus Eli part three. I anticipated that neither fan base would want anything to do with this, but I was wrong. My thought process was that the Giants fans would fear losing to the Pats and destroying their perfect Super Bowl record against them -- I was wrong. I also thought Pats fans would fear losing a third time to the Giants in the Super Bowl and never getting that monkey off their back -- I was wrong.

Neither one of these fan bases has any fear of the opposing team. Both are confident that their team would take home the Lombardi trophy. For my money, it would be a great story, and I would have to root for the Giants. The more interesting outcome from someone who does not have a horse in the race is the Giants having New England's number forever in the big game.

Who you got and why?